Welcome to the HIPS PCT Project

From the PBF Survey Coordinator: 

HIPS PBF Survey observations made in spring 2022 may be reported anytime before February 1, 2023. Thanks for your support of this important data gathering activity!

UPDATE: The PCT Project has released two helpful documents:

The first document is a listing of cumulative counts for the PBF Survey years 2021-2022. You can see what has been reported (PBF Yes/No) for 1,338 different cultivars. Please see the “2020 / 2021 Survey Notes” section below for more discussion and a link to the document. Skip to “2020 / 2021 Survey Notes” section.

The second document is a compilation of six existing “PBF lists” into one comparative list. This will provide a useful convenience to those wanting to check an iris against all six lists. It does not incorporate data from the HIPS PBF Survey. Please see the “More PBF Articles and lists” section below to see the names of the six lists and for a link to the document. Skip to the “More PBF Articles and lists” section.

Quick Links:

What is PBF? What is PCT? Although literally translating to purple-based foliage, the acronym PBF has come to also be used as a general reference for the occurrence of purple colorations in parts of the iris other than the blooms. This usage of the acronym has always been a bit awkward and confusing.

We polled around a bit and decided the term purple coloration types and the acronym PCT would do the job better. It literally encompasses all the various types. We hope people agree this helps clarify things and adopt the usage of PCT as well.

With PCT being a new term it will need some  promotion.  Use “purple coloration types” or “PCT” when that is what we actually mean, and do not use “PBF” when we mean something other than purple-based foliage.

The purple colors of PCT come from the accumulation of pigments found within a group called anthocyanins. Pigments in this group occur in the blooms as well, helping produce purples, blues and reds. Different factors, both genetic and environmental, determine if and how much pigment accumulates. When PCT do occur they seem to be at their peak during spring and early summer. Further into summer they may fade out completely or become unnoticeable.

A listing of the various PCT:

  • Purple-based foliage (PBF)  – In a general audience it’s good practice to first use the long form at least once before using the acronym.
  • Purple rhizome (PR) – PR being only two letters, it really does help to use full form the first time and perhaps all the time in speaking.
  • Purple-ringed rhizome (PRR)   So close to PR that we need to clarify, “Wasn’t a typo, I mean the rhizome has a purple ring all the way around it.”
  • Purple spathes / bracts / sheaths / bud valves – These terms are used somewhat interchangeably and we don’t see people trying to use acronyms. It’s probably best left that way and to just use the full forms.
  • Purple stalk / stem / branches / pedicels – Same idea of no good acronyms and best used full forms.
  • Purple leaf edge / margin / wire edge – A band of purple along the leaf margin and typically very narrow. No good acronyms and best used full forms.

Click on the link below to go to a page with photo examples and some descriptive comments about the various PCT.

Photos of Purple Coloration Types

The HIPS PBF Survey

The occurrence of PCT is underrepresented in the descriptions of irises and in the general literature. One goal of the Survey is to help correct this underrepresentation. We estimate perhaps two in ten irises are capable of displaying PBF.  Within the 6,000+ cultivars reported to the Member Databank there are likely to be several hundred PBF irises yet to be reported to a central list. There are added more within the irises not reported to the Databank. Since so many of our irises are grown by only one or two members it will take a lot of scouters to find and report them all. YOU may be the key person to get an unrecognized PBF iris on the books.

Display of PBF is useful to the verification and identification process. But there are caveats. Display can be variable within the same cultivar and even within the same clump. (See the photos.) Time of year, soil chemistry, weather and other factors can influence display. It’s possible a PBF-capable iris may at times display no PBF at all. PBF is a useful tool but it must be considered along with other pieces of the ID puzzle. With the help of the members, we will compile multiple observations for each iris and see if any patterns are suggested.

Survey results will be summarized in anonymized reports shared with the members periodically. A report and preliminary HIPS PBF Irises List will be issued in 2022.

2020 / 2021 PBF Survey notes

Many thanks to those who participated in the survey thus far. For 2020 and 2021 combined there were 24 reports, totaling 1,992 iris speciments and 1,338 cultivars. This is a pretty good start towards the informal 6,000 cultivars goal we set back in 2020. We are enthusiastic that 2022 reporting will be the best yet! As noted above we have released a report giving cumulative counts for the years 2021-2022. The document may be viewed by clicking on the link: PBF Survey Cumulative 2021-2022. Please note, before using the document for the first time please click on the small “i” icon next to the document title to see important use guidance information.

Please keep in mind that the PBF Survey is an ongoing data gathering activity. The data is limited to what has been reported by participants so it does not represent a comprehensive “PBF list”.

As is seen in the report there are some irises being reported with mixed PBF-yes / PBF-no observations. This can be expected since occurrence of PBF is a variable trait. It reinforces the desire for multiple reports on each iris to help determine its degree of variability.

Becoming aware of mixed yes/no observations requires people to report PBF-no observations as well as PBF-yes. So, we are very appreciative of reporters who include PBF-no observations.

To illustrate: ‘Lucky Doris’ has a reputation as a ‘PBF iris’. We’ve had two people report ‘Lucky Doris’ as PBF-yes. A third person, for two years in a row, reported ‘Lucky Doris’ as PBF-no. Follow-up found that the PBF-no iris came directly from one of the people who reported it as PBF-yes. So we are sure it is the same iris. All observations were made when the iris was in bloom. It is noticed that the PBF-yes reporters live in cooler climates and the PBF-no reporter lives in a hot climate. Is that a coincidence or a pattern to keep in mind? Do you have ‘Lucky Doris’? Help shed more light on this ‘lucky’ revelation.

The 2022 PBF Survey

The design of the 2022 PBF Survey is the same as for 2020 and 2021 with one important change. In addition to providing the Name of the iris, we now ask for the Originator (Breeder) as well. We have clarified some of the language so please read these instructions. They may be printed for your reference.

The observation window is still the iris’ spring bloom period. This is defined as the time from emergence of spring bloom stalks up until the last bloom is spent. Focusing on spring bloom makes comparing different people’s observations more apples-to-apples because the irises are synchronized in the same stage of their yearly cycle.

If someone wants to submit observations of PBF or other PCT outside the spring bloom period please submit as a separate report. These are welcome but still do try to make spring bloom your top priority.

TIP – If you have already reported on some named iris then there is no need to report on that name again unless you note it’s PBF behavior changed, before was Yes and then became No, or vice-versa. This makes it a less onerous task to prepare yearly report.

The Survey is open to anyone whether they are a HIPS member or not. If your time is limited but you want to participate then please place particular priority on reporting irises that you know are uncommon and rare. The Member Databank will tell you how many members grow a particular iris.

We have created forms that you can use in the garden and to prepare your final report. Download links are below. Reporting instructions:

  • Pieces of information we need are:
    • The iris’ name. Please check for correct spelling
    • The originator (or breeder) of the iris. Iris Class and Introduction date are helpful but optional.
    • The observation: a simple Yes (has PBF) or No (no PBF visible)
    • Optional additional helpful comments: Color is faint / Color is pale, etc.
    • Your name and email address or phone number if we need to contact you
    • The observations year
    • Zip code (We are interested in the general climates of reporters.)
  • Observation must be made during the iris’ spring bloom period. This is defined as the time the iris’ spring bloom stalks are emerging up until the last bloom is spent. PBF decision should be made during a direct visual check. Determining PBF from photographs after the fact can be risky! Faint / pale purple is a tricky color in photography.
  • Reported irises should be historic, thirty years old or more. Twenty-nine year old irises may be included. Irises introduced after 1993 should not be included in the reports.
  • Reports from HIPS non-members are encouraged but please note if you are a non-member.
  • Reported irises need to be confirmed as correct or what some call verified. Reasonable measures the PBF Survey asks for are:
    • The iris came to you already named. Unless you are very knowledgeable and experienced, please do not report on irises you identified from noids or unknowns. In any event, if you do report on an identified noid then please note that as added comment. We will keep the data but we want to flag it.
    • Sources: We don’t need to know your source but preferably you remember it yourself.
    • Confirmation Exam(s) have been made of the reported specimen including the specimen’s blooms.
    • An AIS Iris Encyclopedia check has been made and the iris does not obviously conflict with information found there and/or other reliable sources, e.g. in the HIPS Historic Iris Gallery. (Shaub Dunkley, the current coordinator, will be the first to say that his irises often bloom notably below description heights. And he isn’t overly picky about bloom-season either.)
    • All this said, the Survey Coordinator believes as conservationists, we have to relax the rules a bit for irises that are at-threat of being lost. These are the rare irises where there may be only be one to three HIPS members holding them and the iris may have no retail source. (Sadly, this is true for a very large number of the Member Databank irises.) With such irises the most important thing is to get description data on record for the underlying iris, whatever it is. If you have no reason to doubt your rare iris’ name or are neutral about it, don’t be timid – get the data to the survey team; we can check against the Member Databank and Retail Sources data and do follow ups with you after the fact.
  • We do not keep records on the PBF of noids and unknowns.

What to do if you have two irises obtained under the same name and they look the same except for differences in PBF / PCT? And you can’t find anything in the literature to help sort this out. This can and does happen. Contact us and we can discuss what seems the best course of action.

Survey Form Downloads

The same form is available in several formats. All are already set up to print as letter-sized portrait. Please contact the Coordinator if you have any trouble downloading or opening the file.

PBF Survey Form(Excel .XLS)
PBF Survey Form (Word .DOC)
PBF Survey Form (.PDF)

There are four options for sending in reports. For all options please include all information specified above. Deadline for submitting reports is January 31, 2023.

  1. Transfer the observations back to one of the electronic forms provided and email as an attachment.
  2. Create an electronic document of your own and email. Some people submit their own spreadsheet and this is fine.
  3. Type the report into the body of an email and send. This works well for short reports.
  4. Write up the report on paper and mail it in. Contact the Survey Coordinator for a mailing address.

More PBF Articles and lists

The six separate lists named below have been combined into one comparative document which may be viewed by clicking on this link: PBF Irises – Combined Lists. Please note, before using the document for the first time please click on the small “i” icon next to the document title to see important use guidance information.

ID Groundwork: PBF (article)
PBF Iris to 1939 (article)
AIS Iris Encyclopedia PBF page
PBF list on Cubits.org
Shadowood PBF list
Société Française des Iris et plantes Bulbeuses  (PBF list)

More PCT study possibilities?

At this time the PBF Survey is the only active work under the PCT Project umbrella. However, there could be other HIPS PCT surveys or studies active if there are people interested in conducting them. If you are interested in something along these lines please contact the PBF Survey Coordinator to discuss how activities might be coordinated.

Some of us already have personal observation records for other PCT. Potentially these records could be useful to future PCT Project work. If you have such records and are interested in contributing them to the general Project ‘file cabinet’ then contact the PBF Survey Coordinator and we can discuss.

For any questions and comments about the PBF Survey or PCT Project please contact the Survey Coordinator at [email protected]